MassMutual's Innovative New Variable Annuity is a Wolf In Sheep’s Clothing

MassMutual has just introduced a new Variable Annuity product called Equity Edge. That may not seem like news, since nearly every single insurance carrier already offers variable annuities, a hybrid of insurance and securities features (which are often confused with indexed annuities, which are NOT securities but are pure insurance products.) So, what is new about the MassMutual product?

Previously, most variable annuities, regardless of the company who issued them, were similarly structured. In exchange for the ability to choose the underlying investment options and with the potential for market gains, the client assumed ALL investment risk on the value of a variable annuity. The only guarantee in these products was usually a death benefit, for which the client actually paid anyway as an expense deducted regularly from the contract principle to purchase term life insurance. Therefore, the big draw to variable annuities was the high market-based potential return aspects of the securities side, that were also tax deferred as part of the insurance aspects of the product. When the market was rising, those gains could be comfortably deferred inside the annuity and the client could enjoy additional compounding on the earnings they otherwise would lose annually to pay taxes.

For this reason variable annuities became very popular during the huge market increases of the late 90’s. But when the market began to correct in 2000, clients learned that the contract really DID NOT guarantee the account value, and many people suddenly were sitting on an annuity whose value was worth only a fraction of their original deposit. This dissatisfaction in the performance of these products has lead to some variations of variable annuities, the latest of which is this MassMutual version.

The common element of any changes in variable annuities involves the appearance of guarantees. One such product was so confusing that agents themselves were telling clients the product had an underlying guarantee of a fixed rate, at the time about 7%, with the potential of earning more if the market did well. What the truth was, however, was much different. The client only received the guaranteed interest IF, and only IF they left their money in the contract for the full 10 year deferral period followed by a required 10 year systematic withdrawal. When you did the math, essentially what you got was about a 3 ½ % overall return, and then only if you were willing to wait 20 years to get it. Amazingly, this product has been voluntarily withdrawn from the market.

The MassMutual product has similar illusory elements that must be mentioned to avoid client deception. It is called a simplified variable annuity, which in this case means much of the typical flexibility and a number of client options are simply removed. In other words, in the MassMutual product the benefit period is absolute or all guarantees are off. For instance, if someone selects a 10 year period, if for any reason they must withdraw their money before the 10 years is up, they receive NONE of the guaranteed benefits. Ironically one of the simplifications also removes all direction of investment choices from the buyer, previously one of the major selling points of variable annuities. Instead, the product is designed to be managed by MassMutual to integrate fixed interest earnings with equity investments and rebalance them each year in order to attempt to mimic the returns of the S&P 500 on the investement side, with a minimal attempt to just simply preserve the original principle of the entire account.

If you carefully examine it, this product seems remarkable structured like all of the negative aspects that indexed annuities are confusingly accused of having by those who are critical of them, but really don’t. Considering that with an indexed annuity over the contract term you can also get the general potential performance of the S&P 500, BUT the client retains the guaranteed return of 100% of their principle AND a minimum guaranteed interest return, regardless of how the market performs. In addition, with an indexed annuity your gains are locked in annually, and you have penalty free withdraws, usually in the amount of 10% per year throughout the surrender period. If they need more than the penalty free withdrawal, the client can always access whatever amount they need, usually without affecting previous earnings, but simply by paying the applicable surrender charge only on the amount withdrawn over the free amount. Indexed annuities also usually carry a nursing home waiver where in extreme circumstances, such as a nursing home stay, the free withdrawal is increased, or the early withdrawal penalty is removed altogether.

It is clear to me that the MassMutual product is a poor attempt to mimic what the uniformed believes indexed annuities to be on the surface, without really understanding them or how they work. But by missing the REAL features that make an indexed annuity the very appealing and valuable retirement vehicle it is, this MassMutual product is just a piece of crap, and the only way it can be sold is to some unsuspecting buyer who simply trusts the agent or the product because of the MassMutual name. If only that same person was able to have any of the many good indexed annuities to compare to, they would wisely choose the indexed annuity over this MassMutual variable annuity every time.